PR-1 — Patient Responsibility (Deductible/Coinsurance/Copay)
The payer has processed and approved the claim; this specific dollar amount is the patient's contractual share of the cost (deductible, coinsurance, or copay), not a payer denial of the service itself.
Guided troubleshooter available for this denial
Answer a few questions to reach the correct disposition. No patient or claim identifiers requested.
In plain language
The payer has processed and approved the claim; this specific dollar amount is the patient's contractual share of the cost (deductible, coinsurance, or copay), not a payer denial of the service itself.
Start here
Confirm the PR amount matches the plan's stated deductible/coinsurance/copay structure.
Who resolves it
Patient Financial Services/Billing
Who prevents it
Registration/Patient Access — pre-service financial counseling and liability estimates.
Sources
- X12 CARC list
Validated ClaimetryX Source — Denial Management Knowledge Base, 2026 Research Edition
Research date August 18, 2026. CARC/RARC combinations and payer processes vary. Always check the specific remittance advice and the payer's current requirements before acting on any denial.
Published by ClaimetryX. Sources identify the code standards, agency guidance, and payer policies supporting this reference. How we use sources
How to resolve this denial, step by step
- 1
Confirm the PR amount matches the plan's stated deductible/coinsurance/copay structure.
- 2
Check for secondary coverage that might cover some or all of the patient liability.
- 3
If a secondary payer applies, bill secondary before billing the patient.
- 4
If no other coverage applies and the amount is correctly calculated, proceed with standard patient billing/collections workflow.
- 5
Document any discrepancy found and correct with the payer if the PR amount appears miscalculated.
Then choose the correct disposition
Patient responsibility
the standard, expected outcome when correctly calculated and no other coverage applies.
COB correction
if a secondary payer should have been billed first.
Payer follow-up
if the PR amount appears inconsistent with the plan's stated benefit design.
Stop and escalate when
- Patient disputes the liability calculation; possible dual-eligible/QMB status not yet flagged (billing this population directly for Medicare cost-sharing can violate federal balance-billing rules); secondary coverage discovered after billing has begun.
What Needs to Be Corrected
- Claim correction: Only if the PR amount appears calculated incorrectly relative to the plan's actual benefit structure (rare; typically a payer processing question, not a claim data fix).
- Upstream correction: Registration/Patient Financial Services should provide accurate liability estimates and financial counseling before the service when possible.
Do Not Do This
- Do not bill the patient before confirming no secondary payer or regulatory limitation (e.g., Medicaid, QMB "dual eligible" balance-billing prohibitions) applies.
- Do not treat a PR adjustment as a claim error requiring correction without verifying the underlying benefit calculation.
Plain-Language Meaning
- The payer has processed and approved the claim; this specific dollar amount is the patient's contractual share of the cost (deductible, coinsurance, or copay), not a payer denial of the service itself.
Why This Amount Applies
- Patient/COB information: patient's deductible has not yet been met for the benefit period, or the plan design requires coinsurance/copay for this service type
- Registration: patient not informed of estimated liability before the service (a financial- counseling gap, not a claims error)
Information the Biller Must Review
- ERA/EOB adjustment amounts and codes, patient's plan benefit summary (deductible/coinsurance/copay structure), patient's accumulator status (deductible met-to- date), any secondary coverage that might offset the liability (cross-reference D04).
Sample Scenario
- Scenario: Patient balance shown as PR-1/PR-2 on the EOB.
- Finding: Deductible had not been met; no secondary coverage exists.
- Action: Standard patient statement generated per normal billing cycle; no claim correction needed.
Denial Identifier
- Primary CARCs (Group Code PR): CO-1/PR-1 — "Deductible Amount." PR-2 — "Coinsurance Amount." PR-3 — "Co-payment Amount." (X12)
- These are standard, expected patient-liability adjustments, not typically "denials" in the sense of an error — they are included here because the user's revenue-cycle team must correctly distinguish them from true denials.
- Common RARCs: generally none required; occasionally an alert RARC (e.g., appeal-rights language) accompanies the EOB sent to the patient.
Prevention Control
- Pre-service benefit and liability estimation at registration; secondary-coverage/COB check before generating a patient statement; QMB/dual-eligible balance-billing restriction checks before billing Medicaid-eligible patients.
Department Most Likely Responsible
- Resolves current account: Patient Financial Services/Billing. Prevents recurrence (of patient confusion/complaints): Registration/Patient Access — pre-service financial counseling and liability estimates.
AI Answer Guardrail
- Confirm there is no secondary payer, QMB/dual-eligible status, or other regulatory/contractual restriction on billing the patient before advising that a PR amount should be collected from the patient.
AI Search Terms / Synonyms
- PR1; PR2; PR3; patient responsibility; deductible; coinsurance; copay; balance billing.
Work this denial faster
Denial trackers, corrected-claim checklists, and appeal templates.
Get denial trackers & appeal templates